SafeSwitch case study · Private members club, London · live since 23 September 2026 · from the Internet Archive and the live site

ARRIBA went from a five-page site to a twelve-page members club, on pages about a tenth of the weight.

ARRIBA’s old site was five pages. The rebuild kept every address that carried content, retired one empty form page on purpose, and grew the site to twelve pages, each with a search description (0 of 5 before). On the four pages that exist on both sites, the code dropped from 163 KB to 14 KB and the scripts from 54 to 4. We compared the Internet Archive’s copies of the old pages (11 July 2026) with the live site. For how the work ran week to week, see the ARRIBA operations case study.

From five pages to a members club

The Internet Archive’s copies of the five old pages (11 July 2026), against the live site on 17 November 2026.

The old siteBuilt for ARRIBA
PagesBefore5Now12
Pages with a search descriptionBefore0 of 5Now12 of 12
Pages with one main headingBefore2 of 5Now12 of 12
Average page size (HTML, four shared pages)Before163 KBNow14 KB
Scripts per page (same four pages)Before54Now4
Images with a descriptionBefore25 of 27Now40 of 40
What search and AI can readBeforeThe same generic block on every pageNowLocal business, events, membership list, menus

The old site could not be speed-tested, so we show what it carried, not how fast it loaded.

What changed for the club

  • A page for every membership tier. Society, Patrón and Corporate each have their own page with apply buttons, plus a Cultural Programme that lists events a search engine can read.
  • Food and drink, properly. The menus and wine list are published as documents on a Food & Drinks page.
  • Two purpose-built forms. Book a tour and Apply for membership replaced a single bare form page.
  • Files built for AI assistants. An llms.txt with the three tiers and their published prices, and a robots.txt that names 10 AI crawlers, both live as of 17 November.

And nothing was lost along the way

  • The home page, /book-a-tour, /enquiry and /member-form all work at the same address, with and without a trailing slash. Unknown addresses return a real 404.
  • The one address that does not work, /contact-form, was a bare form page titled “Form | Arriba”. It was replaced by two purpose-built pages, Book a tour and Apply for membership, both reached from /enquiry.
  • Every one of the 12 live pages has a search description and exactly one main heading. On the old site, none of the 5 had a description, and 3 of 5 had no main heading.
Previous site addressOn arriba.london today
/Works
/book-a-tourWorks
/enquiryWorks
/member-formWorks
/contact-formRetired on purpose: a bare form page, replaced by /book-a-tour and /member-form, both reached from /enquiry
Page quality, in full
What we countedBeforeAfter
Pages with a search description (old 5, live 12)012
Pages with exactly one main heading (old 5, live 12)212
Images with a description (old 5 pages, live 12)25 of 2740 of 40
Pages with a canonical tag pointing to themselves (old 5, live 12)512
Scripts per page, average (the four pages on both sites)544
Page HTML, average (the four pages on both sites)163 KB14 KB

Speed today

A baseline, not a comparison. The old site could not be measured, so there is no before figure and no claim of improvement. Lighthouse 12, median of 3 runs, 17 November 2026.

PageDevicePerformanceLCP
HomeMobile854.2s
HomeDesktop1000.6s
Book a tourMobile991.6s
Book a tourDesktop1000.5s

Readable by search and AI

  • Markup that fits each page. The old site carried the same generic block on every page: an organisation, a website and a search box. The live site marks up what each page is: a local business on the home page, events on the Cultural Programme, a membership list, menus as documents, and contact pages.
  • Sitemap. All 12 live pages, listed in robots.txt.
  • robots.txt. Names 10 AI crawlers individually: 6 search and assistant bots and 4 training bots (added on 17 November).
  • llms.txt. Live (added on 17 November): who ARRIBA is, the address, the three membership tiers with their published prices, the cultural programme, and the pages and contact details. The Internet Archive has no copy of one for the old site.

These make the site readable. We do not claim they raise citations or rankings by themselves.

Be straight about

Found on the first check, fixed the same day

On 17 November the check found that canonical tags had gone missing on 11 of the 12 pages, and that the site had no llms.txt or AI crawler rules. All three are now live and checked.

How the old site was measured

The old pages come from the Internet Archive, captured on 11 July 2026, about ten weeks before the rebuild began. It covers pages it captured, and the old site may have changed in between. We did not take a before snapshot with Lighthouse, so speed is reported as a baseline only. The home page on a phone is the slowest page, at 85 with the main image taking 4.2 seconds.

Not measured

Rankings, traffic and enquiries. This shows URL continuity and page quality, not an outcome.

Five pages became twelve, each with a description, a main heading and markup that fits the page, on pages about a tenth of the weight. Four of five old addresses kept, and the fifth retired on purpose.

How we measured this

  • Chad’s SafeSwitch approach, adapted for a site that had already moved. The Internet Archive’s copies of the five old pages (11 July 2026) were compared with the live site, and all 12 pages in the live sitemap were read for the same checks.
  • Page counts come from the HTML the server sends. Images with a description are images with non-empty alt text.
  • Page-quality comparisons of code size and scripts use the four pages that exist on both sites.

Moving your own site? See how SafeSwitch works, or more client results in the case studies.

How does your site look to Chad?

Drop your domain. In 11 seconds you get your GEO score, your biggest gap, and the first thing Chad would fix.

Free scan, usually under a minute. No sign-up.